By Rob Douglas, Co-founder & CEO, Left Off Madison
Left Off Madison created, produced, and launched four new advertising campaigns for one client. One for each brand in the portfolio.
Four brands. Four campaigns. All four launched. If you’ve ever taken even one campaign from the first creative presentation all the way to launch, take a second with that.
Now ask me who gave final creative approval on all four campaigns.
I did. On behalf of the client.
I approve creative work all the time. Usually, my approval means I’m ready to put Left Off Madison’s name behind a recommendation, take it into a client meeting, and defend it. On these four campaigns, the client team couldn’t make the final call on the finished television ads and companion digital and print ads. I had to make it.
We told the client we considered the finished creative approved, final and were sending the assets to our media team. No response. All four campaigns went live.
Every so often, a client tells me our team knows their brands better than they do. Coming from someone who lives with those brands every day, that’s one hell of a compliment. It tells me they see how much of themselves our people have put into the business. We get attached. We want to know who’s buying, what brings them back, and why somebody standing in front of the same shelf reaches for a competitor. And once the campaign runs, we want to know whether we gave that person a reason to reach for our client’s brand the next time.
Our attachment to that brand mattered when I had to approve those four campaigns. I knew how much work my team had put into each one. I also cared enough about each brand to send the work back if it needed another round. As the person running the agency, I’d already asked, Is this the strongest work we can recommend? Wearing the CMO’s hat meant asking one more question. Knowing what else this brand could do with its money, would I put it behind this campaign?
There’s a familiar sequence in advertising. The client writes the brief. The agency recommends the work. The client makes the call. What I’m seeing at Left Off Madison is that the first and last steps are increasingly open for discussion.
Sometimes a marketer calls us because sales are slipping and they want us to figure out what deserves a brief in the first place. Sometimes they have the research and need us to say which audience we’d spend against and why. And on those four campaigns, I found myself making the decision I’d ordinarily ask the client to make.
I still ran the agency. The client still owned the business. But for that decision, I had to think like the CMO. Would I put the brand’s money behind my own team’s recommendation? And did I know the business well enough to answer honestly?
What Happens After The Research Presentation?
One client told me their whole company was getting numb to data. That word, numb, stuck with me. They had sales figures, consumer research, and campaign results. What they wanted was a recommendation they could take into the next meeting. Where are we losing ground? Why do you think it’s happening? If we have money for one move this quarter, what would you do?
Consider what it takes to answer that last question. Fewer households buying the brand, regular buyers purchasing less often, and a retailer dropping the product can all produce the same downward line on Monday morning’s sales report. Each one calls for a different response. Get the diagnosis wrong and you can spend a quarter making beautiful advertising for a product shoppers can no longer find in their store.
Marketers have been describing this difficulty for years. In a 2017 edition of The CMO Survey, 388 senior marketers reported that their companies used available or requested analytics before “making a decision” on an average of 31.6% of projects. One of the biggest barriers was finding people who could connect the analysis to marketing practice. There’s also the question of who has the bandwidth. In Marketing Week’s 2026 Career & Salary Survey, 65.3% of 2,350 marketers said they’d felt overwhelmed in their role during the previous year. cmosurvey-new.fuqua.duke.edu
Some of the recommendations that cross a brand manager’s desk add to the workload. The client service team at one of the world’s biggest media partners had a favorite audience to recommend to one of our clients. Do-it-yourselfers.
What the hell defines a DIYer? Somebody who remodeled their kitchen? A sixteen-year-old who replaced a cracked phone screen? Do I qualify if I assemble a bookcase on Sunday? I figured just about anyone sixteen and up could make the cut. Judging by the partner’s own audience estimate, I wasn’t far off.
Here’s what really got me. Our client manufactured products in four unrelated categories. The media partner kept coming back with the same audience for all four. Even if the same person buys in every one of those categories, what sends them shopping for each? Which purchase are they considering? What would give them a reason to choose our client’s product? Imagine being the brand manager who paid for that recommendation and now has to answer those questions to defend the buy.
I have a similar reaction to a favorite from third-party consumer research. “Early adopters of technology.” Early adopters of what? I can buy a smartphone the week it comes out and hang on to the same camera for ten years. If you’re selling cameras, which half of that sentence would you like to spend your money on?
Suppose the research turned up parents who photograph their kids’ evening games from the bleachers and keep coming home with blurry pictures. Now we have a scene the creative team can shoot, a capability the camera can demonstrate, and an audience the media team can investigate. We can test whether that frustration gives enough people a reason to buy.
What decision can we make after the presentation that we couldn’t make before it? I’d like to hear that question asked and answered while the people who prepared the research are still in the room. (BOOM!)
When Getting Help Becomes Another Job
A former client told me they wanted a new agency partner. They kept putting it off because they absolutely dreaded onboarding one.
I get it. Somebody must dig up the research, explain the portfolio, walk the new team through past campaigns, and tell them why the seemingly obvious idea has already been tried twice. Who gets that assignment? Usually, the person who needed the help in the first place.
And that’s after the search. In a 2023 study by the ANA, 4As, and Advertiser Perceptions, clients estimated that selecting a new agency took an average of 3.2 months when the incumbent wasn’t involved. Imagine reaching the end of that process, opening next week’s calendar, and realizing it’s now your job to teach the winners your business. I can see the appeal of waiting another quarter. www.aaaa.org
I suspect that helps explain why one of our strongest-performing new-business emails carries such a simple message. “You don’t need a finished brief. Just give us a problem worth solving.”
There’s real work hidden in the request for a finished brief. We’re asking a marketer to interpret the research, decide whose behavior needs to change, figure out what might change it, and get colleagues to agree. Sometimes that’s precisely the work they were hoping to hire us to do.
The BetterBriefs global study found that 60% of marketers use the creative process to clarify their own strategy. If you’ve ever made it to round three of creative reviews only to discover that the people in the room still disagree about who the campaign is for, you know what that looks like in practice. www.betterbriefs.com
I’d prefer to have that conversation before you pay us to produce anything. Tell us where sales are soft, send us the research you’ve already commissioned, and give us the benefit of what you’ve tried. We can do the reading. Your time is better spent telling us what only you know. We owe you the effort to learn everything else we can on our own.
Then we owe you a recommendation specific enough to challenge. Here are the buyers we’d put money behind. Here’s what we’d say to them, where we’d reach them, and what we’d need to see in the sales numbers to keep spending.
The Driver, The Engineer, And The Pit Crew
The closest analogy I can think of is Formula One. An agency knows how to be the pit crew. Our people make the work, coordinate the changes, and get everything ready to go. We’re comfortable as the engineer, too, studying the data and recommending an adjustment. On those four campaigns, I found out what it means to do both jobs… and then be handed the steering wheel and helmet.
There’s an uncomfortable part to that arrangement. My agency can make money producing the campaign I recommend. Go back to that brand with shrinking sales. Suppose we learn that shoppers are still buying it at the same rate in the stores that carry it, and the decline tracks back to stores that dropped it. Would I tell the client to hold off on new creative and sit down with the sales team first, even if it cost us the assignment? If I’m going to wear the CMO’s hat, I owe them that call, too.
That’s what connects the unfinished brief to those four campaigns. A marketer ought to be able to call me and say, “Sales are slipping, and we haven’t figured out why.” Once my team has done its homework, that marketer deserves to hear me say, “Here’s what I’d do first. Here’s why. If it were my budget, I’d approve it.”
On those four campaigns, I had to mean that last sentence.
You don’t need a finished brief to have that conversation with Left Off Madison.
What’s one marketing decision your team could use a clear recommendation on — right now?